Greg Schroeder Writes
  • Home
  • Published Works
    • Published Poetry
    • Published Military Monographs
    • Works in Progress
  • About the Author
  • Reviews and Notes
    • Featured Writers
  • Contact
  • Diatribes
  • Family History
  • Trouin Cochrane and Jones

Reviews and Notes

Review - An Army at Dawn

5/23/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture
This book lives up to its hype. Atkinson manages to weave a narrative where all the elements of the war in North Africa are skillfully woven into a single whole - the grand politics that so vexed Eisenhower, the commanders of the units - especially American, French and British, and the individual soldiers themselves. Most importantly he weaves a story of the growth of the Americans - the men and the leaders - one could weave a metaphor of the army as a child, learning its way. Atkinson compares the novice Americans, at all levels, with the veteran British and Germans. Well illustrated with maps and photos this is a must have for those interested in World War II, right on the book shelf with The Longest Day and Guadalcanal Diary.
0 Comments

Review - War at the End of the World

2/22/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture
I wanted to like this book. It is about a part of World War II I have studied little. It is written from an overview perspective, so one should be able to get a good understanding of the theatre. But it was a disaster.

From simple factual errors (p. 88 the Mitchell bomber has only TWO engines), to a clear misunderstanding of military units (p. 146 where the 7th Division is described as having only 2 battalions - a full division has between 6 and 12 battalions plus various other formations), to maps that have none of the locations mentioned in the text they are accompanying, to inconsistency from one paragraph to the next (pp. 101-2 where 75 bombers become 93, unless it was really 108, just a few paragraphs later) Duffy is all over the place.

Unfortunately, he is no better with the people. He gives brief biographies of the players - leaders mostly but some common soldiers too - and they sound good, until they don't. One general is noted as having been commissioned in 1923 but only two pages later to have distinguished himself in World War One when he was but a teen, though no further mention is given.

To round it out, Duffy's descriptions of terrain are also challenged. In one chapter he tells how the Allies decide to build three large airfields in a place which, just two pages before, he has described as having rough mountains marching to within a hundred meters of a mangrove jungle lined shore. Doesn't sound like any place for a large flat airfield!

​I'll continue to look for a good history of the Second World War in New Guinea. This is not it.
0 Comments

Review - Wellington's Guns

12/31/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture

Lipscombe tells a detailed and well researched and documented history of the British artillery of the Peninsular and Waterloo campaigns of the Napoleonic Wars. He details the tension between Wellington and his artillery leaders brought about in no small part by the dual nature of the command structure from London where the artillery technically was not part of Wellington's line of command.
 
To me the most interesting was Lipscombe's discussions about the effectiveness of the new spherical case, or "shrapnel" ammunition first introduced in the Peninsula and in the gradual "bulking up" or the artillery arm, starting with light 6-pounders and ending, at Waterloo, with most batteries fielding 9-pounders. As well as the discussions he brings forward about the effectiveness of mountain guns in Spain and the Pyrenees and the differences between French and British deployments.
 
As one would expect from the title he spends only a little time on the Portuguese artillery that accompanied Wellington's armies and even less on the Spanish guns. However, I found it an excellent read. Recommended for any student of Wellington, or the Napoleonic Wars.

0 Comments

Review - The Philadelphia Campaign by David G. Martin

9/22/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
Martin writes a concise history of a pivotal campaign in the American Revolution. It traces clearly, yet with significant detail, the campaign that included the major battles of Germantown, Brandywine, and Guilford Court House as well as the famous encampment in Valley Forge and a relatively unknown but fascinating struggle for the navigation of the Delaware River from the Atlantic to the city of Philadelphia.

Martin includes vignettes for more detail about key figures, like Baron von Steuben, semi-mythical figures, like Molly Pitcher, and the Hessians who fought for Great Britain. There are many illustrations and several maps.

As with most military histories there are not enough maps. The largest negative with the book, however, was a significant number of typographical errors, including one where the date of an event was entered incorrectly in one paragraph even though it was correct in the immediately preceding paragraph!

​Despite this, and its age (26 years since publication when I read it) the book holds up well and tells an important story.
0 Comments

Review - Four Princes by John Julius Norwich

9/22/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture

Subtitled Henry VIII, Francis I, Charles V, Suleiman the Magnificent and the Obsessions that Forged Modern Europe this fascinating quadruple biography traces the contemporary lives of the four men, sometimes rivals, sometimes allies, who ruled most of Europe for the first half of the 16th century. 
It was, perhaps, a unique half-century, where four skilled monarchs ruled in direct contact with each other. None of their immediate successors was either as successful or ruled as long. Suleiman brought the Ottoman Empire to its peak. Henry laid the groundwork on which Elizabeth made England both a great sea power and a bastion of Protestantism. Charles, arguably, ruled at the height of Habsburg power. He was the most powerful ruler in Europe throughout the period. Finally, Francis, with the weakest position, surrounded as France was by Charles and his subordinates, played the foil skillfully, keeping a balance in Europe and, eventually, breaking up the amalgamated possessions of Charles, leaving his successor, Philip II, weakened and the position of France improved.
The book deals with the monarchs and their wives and mistresses, their courtiers and ambassadors. It delves into their obsessions - Henry's with procuring a male heir, Suleiman with conquest in eastern Europe, Charles and, later, Francis, with religion. Norwich describes the relationships between the four men who knew each other well and, with the exception of Suleiman, spent time with each other. The pomp and extravagance, the patronage and great works are described, providing a fullness to each character as they progress, and age. 
A most excellent biography and history of Europe in the first half of the 16th century. Recommended.
0 Comments

    Author

    Me as a critic (be careful! the harshness will be well concealed!)

    Archives

    February 2022
    July 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    March 2020
    September 2019
    August 2019
    May 2019
    January 2019
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017

    Categories

    All
    Adventure
    Alexander Kent
    American Civil War
    American War For Independence
    Arthur Conan Doyle
    Baseball
    Biography
    Blumesday
    British History
    Cheyenne Bramwell
    Childhood
    Children Mystery
    Children's
    Classics
    Commentary
    Courtroom Drama
    Duel Results
    Emily Dickinson
    Encouragement
    Espionage Thriller
    Fantasy
    Fiction
    Flash Fiction
    Gardening
    Giveaway
    Great American Read
    Historical Fiction
    Holidays
    Humor
    India
    Jessica Mehta
    Kindness
    Legacy
    Lincoln
    Louis L'Amour
    Military History
    Moments
    More Monday
    Mystery
    NanoWritMo
    Napoleonics
    Naval
    Newbery
    Opinion
    Out Of Print
    Photo Book
    Picture Books
    Poetry
    Poetry Duel
    Poul Anderson
    Reading
    Rebecca Bardelli
    Review
    Reviews
    Romance
    Romantic Suspense
    Russo-Japanese War
    Sarah And Lincoln
    Science Fiction
    Scott O'Dell
    Short Story
    Snow
    Sue Grafton
    Suffrage
    Throwback Thursday
    Tsushima
    Tween
    US History
    Walt Whitman
    Western
    World War 2
    World War I
    Writing
    Young Adult

    RSS Feed

    Follow my blog with Bloglovin
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Published Works
    • Published Poetry
    • Published Military Monographs
    • Works in Progress
  • About the Author
  • Reviews and Notes
    • Featured Writers
  • Contact
  • Diatribes
  • Family History
  • Trouin Cochrane and Jones